From the source
Ideogram tested eight AI image editors on a single handbag photo to see which ones make a requested edit without disturbing the rest of the product shot.
- The company ran recolor, strap-removal and background-replacement prompts in Ideogram, ChatGPT, Gemini and Firefly, and reviewed Photoshop, Photoroom, Pixlr and Canva by features and plans instead.
- Ideogram says its masked recolor changed the front panel to burgundy while the handles and side panel stayed brown and the gold clasp stayed in place, which it calls the pick for edits confined to one panel.
- With prompts alone, Ideogram says the front came out plum-toned rather than the requested oxblood, and ChatGPT came closest to the requested oxblood.
- Canva stopped the strap-removal request at an upgrade prompt, and the test used Ideogram Precise Edit with 4.5, Firefly Image 5 at Auto / 2K, a ChatGPT selector showing GPT-6.1 Sol Light, and Gemini's Auto with Images selected.
- Ideogram advises trying the edit you actually need and downloading the result before choosing a tool.





